If you’re planning to sell online, you’ve probably faced a very familiar dilemma: Should I build my own store or sell through a marketplace like Amazon or Shopee? After all, though both an eCommerce platform vs marketplace promise visibility and revenue, they work in completely different ways behind the scenes!
In this guide, we’ll take a closer look at the difference between eCommerce platform and marketplace.
Specifically, this article will discuss:
- Key characteristics of an eCommerce platform
- Key characteristics of a marketplace
- 4 differences between an eCommerce platform vs marketplace
- Which solution is better for your business
- Criteria to choose between an eCommerce Platform vs marketplace
By the end, you’ll be able to decide not just where to sell, but how to grow in the long run. Let's get started!
Key Characteristics of an eCommerce Platform
Before exploring what defines an eCommerce platform (and later on, the difference between an eCommerce platform vs marketplace), it’s helpful to look at its general strengths and limitations:
Pros | Cons |
Full ownership and control over branding, content, and customer data | Requires technical knowledge or external help to build and maintain |
Highly customizable with integrations, apps, and themes | Initial setup costs and subscription fees can be higher than marketplace entry |
Enables long-term customer relationships and brand equity | Traffic generation and marketing are the merchant’s responsibility |
1. Independent store ownership
An eCommerce platform allows merchants to build and operate their own online store without relying on a central authority.
Businesses register a domain name, customize design, upload products, and directly manage pricing, policies, and promotions. The platform itself provides the tools and infrastructure (hosting, checkout, analytics), but the merchant owns the store. Simply put, the business relationship exists directly between the store and its customers, not mediated by any third party.
2. Subscription-based revenue structure
Most eCommerce platforms follow a SaaS (Software-as-a-Service) model, meaning merchants pay a recurring subscription fee that grants access to software, hosting, and support.
Some platforms also offer tiered plans that scale with store size or sales volume, plus optional costs for plugins, themes, or payment processing. This pricing structure gives merchants predictable expenses and flexibility to grow: they pay for functionality and performance, not for every transaction. As a result, their profit margins are directly linked to their business performance rather than platform commission.
3. Full customization and data ownership
Unlike marketplaces, where sellers must follow fixed layouts and policies, eCommerce platforms offer more freedom to shape every part of the user experience.
Merchants can modify design, navigation, product presentation, and even code (in open-source systems like WooCommerce). They also retain ownership of their customer data, including email lists, purchase history, and behavior analytics.
Key Characteristics of a Marketplace
A marketplace operates very differently. It’s a shared ecosystem designed to simplify transactions for multiple sellers under one centralized brand. Here’s how its main advantages and disadvantages compare.
Pros | Cons |
Full ownership and control over branding, content, and customer data | Requires technical knowledge or external help to build and maintain |
Highly customizable with integrations, apps, and themes | Initial setup costs and subscription fees can be higher than marketplace entry |
Enables long-term customer relationships and brand equity | Traffic generation and marketing are the merchant’s responsibility |
1. Multi-seller environment
A marketplace connects multiple independent sellers with buyers on a single platform. Sellers create listings within the marketplace’s framework and follow standard templates and rules.
The marketplace operator manages traffic, payment processing, customer protection, and sometimes even logistics (e.g., fulfillment centers). This shared environment allows sellers to reach customers quickly but limits their ability to control how products appear or how their brand is represented. All interactions occur within the marketplace’s ecosystem, not on a seller-owned website.
2. Transaction-based revenue system
Marketplaces earn revenue primarily through transaction fees and commissions. Each completed sale generates a small percentage that goes to the marketplace operator.
Some also charge additional fees for listing products, running ads, or subscribing to premium seller accounts. This system means the marketplace’s revenue scales with the number of transactions processed, encouraging the operator to attract more buyers and sellers. Though sellers benefit from the platform’s built-in audience, they must share a portion of every sale – a trade-off between reach and profit.
3. Centralized branding and customer experience
In a marketplace, the overall customer experience is designed and controlled by the operator. The brand identity customers remember (such as Amazon, Shopee, or eBay) belongs to the marketplace, not the individual sellers. Hence, product pages follow uniform templates; customer communication, dispute handling, and feedback systems are all centralized.
eCommerce Platform vs Marketplace: Break Down The Difference
Though both an eCommerce platform vs marketplace exist to help businesses sell online, the way they operate and the kind of value they create couldn’t be more different! Below, we’ll break down the four key areas that truly set them apart:
Type of interaction
For starters, the most fundamental difference between an eCommerce platform vs marketplace lies in how people interact within them.
An eCommerce platform functions as a complete system that allows a business to create and manage its own online store. In this model, there are only two main parties involved: the merchant and the customer.
The platform provider (such as Shopify, WooCommerce, or BigCommerce) simply offers the infrastructure and tools, like website templates, checkout systems, and payment gateways. Meanwhile, the merchant handles everything else, from product listings and marketing to customer support and fulfillment.
By contrast, a marketplace serves as an intermediary between multiple sellers and buyers, all operating within one centralized system. Amazon, eBay, and Shopee are good examples. Here, transactions take place under the marketplace’s structure: sellers list products, buyers make purchases, and the marketplace handles payments, logistics, and sometimes even customer service. The interaction is standardized and transactional; buyers engage mainly with the marketplace brand, not with individual sellers.
Revenue model
These structural differences naturally shape how an eCommerce platform vs marketplace earns money.
A marketplace primarily monetizes each transaction. Its core engine is commissions or referral fees taken per sale, often supplemented by listing fees, seller subscriptions, paid promotions, and logistics or fulfillment charges where offered. In other words, revenue scales directly with GMV and the number of completed orders.
Likewise, an eCommerce platform can also earn from transaction fees in certain contexts. For example, app stores take a cut of app sales or in-app purchases, and platforms add a margin on payment processing.
Still, in most other cases, platforms also typically rely on diversified revenue streams beyond pure per-sale commissions: advertising (e.g., social platforms), subscriptions (e.g., premium tiers like LinkedIn Premium or SaaS plans for store software), and in-app purchases (e.g., gaming ecosystems).
Simply put, marketplaces monetize the sale itself, whereas platforms usually monetize access, tools, or audience, while still taking a transaction cut in specific product categories.
Value creation
Next, the way value is created in an eCommerce platform vs marketplace also differs significantly.
A marketplace generates value through aggregation. By bringing together a large pool of sellers and buyers, it creates convenience and efficiency for both sides. Buyers enjoy variety, competitive prices, and quick transactions, whereas sellers gain access to an existing audience without needing to build traffic from scratch. The more people join and interact, the more valuable the marketplace becomes.
In contrast, an eCommerce platform creates value through empowerment. Instead of connecting existing demand and supply, it provides merchants with the tools to build and differentiate their own online presence. Merchants can design their websites, customize their branding, and develop marketing strategies tailored to their audience. The platform’s value grows as merchants innovate by launching new products, using advanced integrations, and improving customer experiences.
In short, marketplaces create collective value by connecting many users, while eCommerce platforms create individual value by enabling independence and growth.
Control over branding
Finally, the most visible distinction lies in branding control.
As mentioned briefly earlier, on a marketplace, sellers operate under the marketplace’s identity.
Product pages follow standard templates, and branding opportunities are limited. Buyers usually remember the marketplace name (like Amazon or Lazada) rather than the specific seller. Though this gives sellers exposure to a massive audience, it also means they sacrifice brand ownership. Customer data and communication channels are typically controlled by the marketplace, making it harder for sellers to build direct relationships or long-term loyalty.
An eCommerce platform, however, offers complete ownership over branding and customer experience. Merchants can use their own domain name, customize every visual element, and control how their brand communicates with customers. They also have full access to customer data, allowing for personalized marketing, retargeting, loyalty programs, etc. Such autonomy enables merchants to build long-term brand equity and distinct identity – something a shared marketplace environment cannot offer.
eCommerce Platform vs Marketplace: Which Is For You?
As you can see, both an eCommerce platform vs marketplace can be profitable, but each suits a different stage and type of business.
If you’re a new or small seller, a marketplace offers the fastest path to selling online.
You don’t need to worry about building a website, buying a domain, or handling payment systems; everything is ready for you. The marketplace already has a steady flow of buyers, so you can reach customers immediately and start generating revenue quickly. Plus, this model works well if your priority is visibility and sales rather than brand-building.
On the other hand, for established businesses, brand-focused entrepreneurs, or manufacturers that want to own customer relationships and present a distinct image, an eCommerce platform is the better route.
You’ll need to invest more time and money upfront (creating your store, setting up payment gateways, driving traffic yourself, etc.), but you gain full control over your business. You decide how your products look, how your brand is represented, and how customers experience your store. Over time, this control allows you to build brand loyalty and grow sustainably without depending on a third-party marketplace.
How to Choose between eCommerce Platform vs Marketplace for Your Business
To choose between an eCommerce platform vs marketplace, you need to think carefully about your business goals, resources, and growth potential. Below are four key criteria to help guide your decision:
Business goals and growth vision
Ask yourself: What is my main objective?
If your goal is to make sales quickly and validate your products in the market, a marketplace makes sense. Just like renting a stall in a busy market, you instantly get foot traffic, but you don’t control the space. You’ll rely on marketplace policies and must compete for visibility among many sellers.
On the other hand, if your goal is to build a sustainable brand that customers recognize and return to, an eCommerce platform is more suitable. Here, you’re not only selling products but also creating a business asset that grows in value. You can customize every aspect of your store, from the visuals to the tone of communication, and build customer trust over time.
Budget and operational resources
Think realistically about what you can afford, not just in money, but in time and skills.
A marketplace is low-cost to start because the operator handles technical tasks like hosting, payment, and security. You simply list your products and start selling. The downside is that you’ll pay commissions per sale, which reduces your profit margins over time.
Meanwhile, an eCommerce platform requires a higher initial investment, including subscription fees, domain purchase, store design, and marketing. You’ll also need to manage fulfillment and customer service. However, your ongoing costs become more predictable, and you keep most of your profits.
Market competition and product type
Last but not least, consider how crowded your industry is and what sets your product apart.
In a marketplace, competition is fierce because customers can compare prices and products instantly. If your business depends on competitive pricing or high-volume sales (like electronics accessories, clothing, or daily-use goods), marketplaces are ideal since you benefit from their existing traffic and user trust.
However, if your products are unique, premium, or brand-driven, a platform allows you to showcase their value more effectively. You can design a branded shopping experience that highlights craftsmanship, storytelling, or exclusivity, all of which usually get lost in a marketplace’s standardized listing.
Essentially, marketplaces are better for selling common, price-sensitive items. Meanwhile, platforms are better for differentiated or high-value products.
eCommerce Platform vs Marketplace: FAQs
What is the difference between a marketplace and an eCommerce platform?
The main difference lies in ownership and structure. A marketplace is a centralized system operated by a third party that connects multiple independent sellers with buyers. An eCommerce platform, on the other hand, is a software solution that allows an individual business to build and manage its own online store.
Is Amazon a marketplace or eCommerce?
Amazon is primarily a marketplace, not a traditional eCommerce platform. It allows millions of independent sellers to list and sell products directly to customers through Amazon’s ecosystem. Amazon handles payment processing, order fulfillment, and customer service in many cases (especially through Fulfillment by Amazon, or FBA).
Is a marketplace considered eCommerce?
Yes, absolutely. A marketplace is a form of eCommerce, but not the only one. The term eCommerce broadly refers to any form of buying and selling conducted online. Within that category, there are different models, including single-vendor eCommerce stores (built on platforms like Shopify or WooCommerce) and multi-vendor marketplaces (like Amazon or Etsy).
Is Facebook Marketplace an eCommerce platform?
Facebook Marketplace is not a full eCommerce platform; it’s a peer-to-peer marketplace feature within Facebook’s social network. It allows users to list and sell items locally or through shipping, but it doesn’t provide complete eCommerce functionality such as branded storefronts, custom domains, or integrated marketing tools.
Conclusion
At the end of the day, the real question isn’t which model is “better” between an eCommerce platform vs marketplace, but which one fits the kind of business you’re building.
All in all, the marketplace offers speed; it’s the shortcut to getting your products in front of buyers. But a platform offers ownership and gives you the chance to create a brand that’s truly yours. The key is to understand what you want to achieve, how much independence you need, and how you define growth!
For more eCommerce tips, check out our blog or join our Facebook Community.
